Limyaael

Previous Entry Add to Memories Tell a Friend Next Entry
08:40 pm: Book reviews: Bear and Monette, Morgan

Comments

[User Picture]
From:[info]limyaael
Date:November 17th, 2007 07:07 pm (UTC)
(Link)
Hope you enjoy it! It's one of those books where I can imagine the sex and the violence putting a lot of people off, but I saw them as valid storytelling choices. If you can deal with the prologue, I think the rest of the story will work for you.

Re. the no female wolfcarls...I know that it wasn't explicitly mentioned,

Your explanation may well be right. I was just surprised because most of the other gender roles in the book are explicitly mentioned and explore. And most societies that are male-dominated have always had some sort of explanation as to why women can't participate in [insert activity here]. I was watching for that explanation and how it applied to trellwolves, and I didn't see it. I do think it's a plothole.
From:[info]kaiz
Date:November 18th, 2007 10:06 am (UTC)
(Link)
It's one of those books where I can imagine the sex and the violence putting a lot of people off,

I confess, I *love* carnage, so no worries there! ;-)

I was watching for that explanation and how it applied to trellwolves, and I didn't see it. I do think it's a plothole.

I totally agree. It did seem surprising that there weren't any female fighters at all (at least, if there were any, I missed them amidst the metric shit load of minor characters! :-). There didn't seem to be any explicit social prohibition against it...it would be nice if the authors addressed it in a sequel (which they're apparently thinking about, after their other current projects are completed).

I did really like the way that the troll genocide *wasn't* swept under the rug; and I thought that Isolfr's plans for his daughter were interesting both from a gender standpoint (as his reaction to his observations about the female smith) and also from a political standpoint as well. Good stuff. My main complaint with the book was that it was too short!
Powered by InsaneJournal